Maxson McDowell PhD, LMSW, LP is a senior Jungian analyst who has
practiced in New York City for the past 22 years. He is also a past president
of the C. G. Jung Foundation in New York. Here he analyzes a tale from the Yakut people of Siberia.
The little old woman with five cows (Yakut)
Story: C.W. Daniel Company from Siberian and Other Folktales: Primitive Literature of the Empire of the Tsars, collected and translated by C. Fillingham Coxwell, copyright 1925.Analyzing the tale
I interpret this fairy story according to the internal logic of its structure and by staying close to the details of each image and considering the implications of those details. I look for internal repetitions, in which a similar interpretation is suggested by a series of details, or by a series of different images. I compare this story with similar stories. Above all, I check my interpretation against clinical observations. Does it accurately describe developments which I see repeatedly with my patients? Does it deepen my understanding of those developments? If my interpretation satisfies all these criteria then it "rings true" for me. I use similar criteria for interpreting dreams except that, when the dreamer is present, the interpretation must also ring true for the dreamer and the dreamer must have a bodily reaction which signals that assent.
Of course, the story can be interpreted in other ways. I try to use the word "suggests" to convey this but when I use "is" or "represents" these also should be understood as probabilities not absolutes.
n indescribable beauty and the devil's daughter 